Orangutan News: Rehabilitated Orangutans in Danger if Industrial Project Proceeds

Industrial area in Kalimantan. Photo courtesy of Stanislav Lhota

by Caillie Mutterback at Mongabay.com

The proposed extension of an industrial area in East Kalimantan, Indonesia will likely mean the end of a population of rehabilitated orangutans who reside there, according to the Indonesian environmental group Peduli Teluk Balikpapan. The Kariangau Industrial Area (KIK) will comprise 5,130 hectares of land currently covered by hardwood forests and mangroves when completed, including one third of orangutan habitat in Sungai Wain forest—a crucial portion that is not within the boundaries of the Sungai Wain Protection Forest and therefore not under any governmental protection. Though the expansion has not yet been finalized, two companies—PT Dermaga Kencana Indonesia (Kencana Agri Ltd. Group) and PT Mekar Bumi Andalas (Wilmar Group)—have proceeded to clear forest and reclaim mangrove swamps in areas still classified as protected in order to build crude palm oil mills near Upper Balikpapan Bay.

The Sungai Wain orangutans are part of a rehabilitation program established by the Borneo Orangutan Survival Foundation in the 1990s. Over 80 orangutans have been released into the surrounding primary and secondary forests, including the famous orphaned orangutan Uce. However the population is already imperiled by orangutan killing.

“The orangutan population in Sungai Wain has been well established and almost all females are now being accompanied by one or two infants or juveniles,” Dr. Stanislav Lhota, a primatologist and researcher who works with Peduli Teluk Balikpapan, told mongabay.com. “Given this, it is surprising that the total size of the population is just 15-30 individuals, based on our survey of large mammals in and around Sungai Wain in 2006. Although several of the 80-plus orangutans released in Sungai Wain were translocated to Gunung Meratus following the forest fires in 1998, we strongly believe that most of the population disappeared due to opportunistic killing by local people as the animals move out of the forest into encroachment zones along its southern and northern boundaries.”

Orangutans, Uce and Bulan. Photo courtesy of Stanislav Lhota. Orangutans, Uce and Bulan. Photo courtesy of Stanislav Lhota.
One of the reasons Lhota cites for opportunistic hunting are secondary roads that make Sungai Wain accessible.

“Whenever there is a development (big roads, plantations or industry), there is a network of smaller roads going far into the forests. The roads are often created with the primary purpose of land speculations but they are also frequented by hunters,” he says, adding that, “the local people do not target orangutans for hunting but given the opportunity, they may kill them.”

Though Lhota notes that Sungai Wain Protection Forest is relatively well protected by patrols, one third of the orangutan’s habitat is not within the boundaries.

“The animals apparently depend on the unprotected area and move frequently between the protected and unprotected forest,” Lhota explains, adding that in the unprotected forest, “there is no wildlife protection at all.”

Increased hunting is only part of the problem with the expansion. Development from the expansion of the KIK would destory 20 percent of the orangutan habitat Lhota said in a press statement.

“The total loss (due to development and resulting encroachment) would be more than 1/3 of the available habitat, based on the experience from the eastern boundaries where the encroachment zone extends to more than 2 kilometers into the forest, and continues to expand even now, despite intensive patrolling by forest guards, police and army, and the legislation, which includes a local decree, which strictly prohibits access to the major part of the Protection Forest.”

Because of encroachment and increased hunting pressure, the rehabilitated Sungai Wain orangutans may be lost in as little as one to two decades. Indonesian Lowlands (on the Island of Borneo) are already “badly affected by logging, forest fires, and fire conversion into agriculture, tree plantation, mining and industry,” according to Lhota.

The proposed expansion of KIK may also mean the collapse of fisheries, bay silting, decline in biodiversity and loss of reputation for the region. The NGO, Peduli Teluk Balikpapan, contends that there are several design flaws in the KIK expansion which could have serious ecological and economic consequences. For example, while Balikpapan Bay is a closed seawater system “most of the freshwater flow that enters the bay from the coastal areas will not be ‘flushed’ into the open waters of the Makasser Strait,” the organization writes in a press release, “instead, [the water] will be blocked and moved back upstream by incoming tides. Thus any sediment and industrial waste will accumulate in the waters of the upper section of the bay where it will settle. In the long term, this would lead to extreme levels of sedimentation and accumulation of dangerous pollutants.”

The fishing industry, a major source of income for the residents of the area, could be threatened if unskilled laborers are unable to get a job working with one of the new companies along the coast. Those that are able to continue fishing must be wary of pollutants and other waste resulting from the industry along with any possible coastal damage.
Because Borneo contains the largest amount of contiguous forest in Asia, there is an enormous amount of endemism in plants and animals. The expansion of industry may result in the loss of not only orangutan populations but numerous protected species living in the forest and the coastal waters. One of these species could be the proboscis monkey, according to Lhota.
Sun bear (Helarctos malayanus) breaking into a bee's nest in Sungai Wain Protection Forest. This species is listed as Vulnerable by the IUCN Red List. Photo courtesy of Stanislav Lhota. Sun bear (Helarctos malayanus) breaking into a bee’s nest in Sungai Wain Protection Forest. This species is listed as Vulnerable by the IUCN Red List. Photo courtesy of Stanislav Lhota.
“The population of proboscis monkeys in the Bay was about 1400 according to the 2007 survey. It is one of the 7 known populations of more than 1000 and it may be as much as 5% of the total viable population of the species,” he says.
According to Peduli Teluk Balikpapan, there are 1,000 species of trees, around 300 species of birds and more than 100 species of animals living in the area. If land is converted for residential or industrial use, many of these unique species could be lost, as numbers are already threatened by industrial development and climate change.
“In the case of the orangutans it is a rather moral issue,” Lhota adds. “The current numbers in Sungai Wain and their extinction will probably not affect the survival of the whole species. But the population is a result of an ex-captive rehabilitation program, which cost considerable effort and which was supported by many people. I believe that the future of such populations needs to be safeguarded, and it should be a shared responsibility of anyone who is involved in orangutan conservation and rehabilitation.
Orangutan rehabilitation would have little meaning if the newly established population is later abandoned and their habitat is left to be allocated for conversion into industry or other use.”
NGOs have further criticized the KIK’s claims, saying their proposals are guilty of greenwashing in order to influence residents that the expansion will have a positive impact on the environment. Critics claim that by using buzzwords and concepts like “Zero Sediment,” “Zero Waste,” the “Green Line (Green Corridor)” and “Foresting the City,” KIK is attempting to subdue arguments from environmental groups. Claims such as “Zero Sediment” and “Zero Waste” can be misleading since there are no ways to guarantee zero sedimentation or waste.
According to the NGO’s reports, coral reefs around the area have already been severely damaged by layers of mud from construction, to the end that more than 50% of them are dead. The proposed Green Corridor has already been extensively damaged by clearing, and the company’s promise to “Forest the City” by replanting mangroves has been deemed unnecessary in areas where mangroves are able to regenerate naturally and does not replace the damage being done to the coastlines and forests outside of the city.
Furthermore, Peduli Teluk Balikpapan argues that the expansion of KIK is not being done for the sake of economic development but rather for land speculations.
“Since the 1990s, people (apparently including some influential people) were buying the forested land around Sungai Wain Protection Forest and Balikpapan Bay for negligible prices (as little as 1-2 million Indonesian Rupees per hectare),” says Lhota. “By lobbying for development of the area, such as the proposed construction of Trans Kalimantan Highway towards the Balang Island or the proposed extension of the Kariangau Industrial Area, they can assure that the prices of the same land may rocket up to 20-30 million per hectare or even more, and they are now selling this land to various corporations, mainly to the highly environmentally irresponsible ones.”
Lhota suggests two alternative areas for the industrial area that he says would be better both for the environment and the economy: either the boundary of Balikpapan and Samboja (Kutai Kartanegara Regency), or the Penajam-Buluminung Area (Penajam Paser Utara Regency).
“Both are flat areas in lower (instead of upper) watershed, completely deforested with better infrastructure,” he says, adding that, “[A] third option is taking better advantage of the existing 2000 hectares of the Kawasan Industrial Area, which is a degraded wasteland that can still be developed, without the real need of the extension in to forested areas.”

Although not necessary to save the species, the extinction of these rehabilitated orangutan would be a serious loss for orangutan conservation efforts everywhere.

Industrial area loading site. Photo courtesy of Stanislav Lhota. Industrial area loading site. Photo courtesy of Stanislav Lhota.
This article originally appeared on Mongabay.com and you can read it in its entirely at http://news.mongabay.com/2012/1022-mutterback-orangutans-sungai-wain.html#RgFJtfdizP7ID7JD.99  Industrial area in Kalimantan. Photo courtesy of Stanislav Lhota.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *